Skip to main content

Table 3 Factors determining probability of being ITC beneficiary

From: Tax incentives and environmental protection: evidence from China’s taxpayer-level data

Dependent variable: ITCdummy

Benchmark sample

Subsample A of benchmark sample

Subsample B of benchmark sample

Independent variables

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

Ownership

 lagForeign

−0.101 (0.176)

−0.151 (0.172)

−0.117 (0.177)

−0.168 (0.173)

−0.122 (0.177)

−0.174 (0.173)

 lagHMT

−0.188 (0.183)

−0.210 (0.180)

−0.201 (0.184)

−0.218 (0.181)

−0.206 (0.184)

−0.223 (0.182)

 lagLshare

0.098 (0.158)

0.084 (0.156)

0.091 (0.159)

0.079 (0.157)

0.089 (0.159)

0.075 (0.157)

 lagPrivate

−0.353** (0.160)

−0.331** (0.159)

−0.371** (0.161)

−0.345** (0.160)

−0.378** (0.161)

−0.350** (0.160)

 lagODomestic

−0.039 (0.144)

−0.078 (0.143)

−0.053 (0.144)

−0.088 (0.144)

−0.058 (0.144)

−0.092 (0.144)

Taxpayer’s other features

 laglnage

−0.113* (0.059)

−0.168*** (0.060)

−0.116** (0.059)

−0.171*** (0.060)

−0.117** (0.059)

−0.171*** (0.060)

 laglnsize

0.373*** (0.027)

0.399*** (0.030)

0.379*** (0.027)

0.405*** (0.030)

0.382*** (0.027)

0.408*** (0.030)

 lagcapital

0.063*** (0.021)

0.055*** (0.020)

0.061*** (0.021)

0.054*** (0.020)

0.060*** (0.021)

0.053*** (0.020)

 lagROA

3.027*** (0.333)

2.863*** (0.339)

3.074*** (0.335)

2.910*** (0.341)

3.084*** (0.335)

2.919*** (0.342)

 lagwage

−0.096 (0.104)

−0.098 (0.100)

−0.098 (0.105)

−0.101 (0.101)

−0.095 (0.105)

−0.099 (0.101)

 laglncoalinput

0.042*** (0.014)

0.022* (0.013)

0.043*** (0.015)

0.023* (0.014)

0.042*** (0.015)

0.023* (0.014)

 laglnfuelinput

−0.006 (0.015)

−0.012 (0.014)

−0.005 (0.015)

−0.012 (0.014)

−0.005 (0.015)

−0.012 (0.014)

Region’s features

 lnrealgdppc

−0.015 (0.059)

−0.031 (0.048)

−0.014 (0.060)

−0.028 (0.048)

−0.013 (0.060)

−0.028 (0.048)

 fiscalauto

−0.072 (0.252)

−0.353* (0.190)

−0.078 (0.256)

−0.343* (0.193)

−0.082 (0.257)

−0.348* (0.193)

 workingpop

0.284 (0.227)

0.291* (0.177)

0.288 (0.228)

0.301* (0.176)

0.282 (0.228)

0.300* (0.176)

 finance

0.030 (0.050)

0.036 (0.037)

0.032 (0.051)

0.040 (0.037)

0.031 (0.052)

0.040 (0.038)

 indlevel

−0.235 (0.214)

−0.202 (0.136)

−0.271 (0.244)

−0.221 (0.147)

−0.283 (0.255)

−0.231 (0.155)

Constant

−4.082*** (0.781)

−3.445*** (0.920)

−4.088*** (0.789)

−3.523*** (0.927)

−4.094*** (0.791)

−3.559*** (0.929)

Year fixed effect

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Province fixed effect

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Province-year fixed effect

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Industry fixed effect

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Industry-year fixed effect

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

Observation

11644

11664

11563

11580

11532

11548

Pseudo R-square

0.234

0.208

0.238

0.213

0.240

0.214

  1. Notes: Superscript symbols “*, **, and ***” represent 10 %, 5 %, and 1 % significant level respectively. The values in parentheses are robust standard errors. Wald χ 2’s p values are all below 0.01. Subsample A of the benchmark sample consists of incumbents in the polluting industries without those who have investment related to ITC in the last year but have no such investment in the current year. Subsample B of the benchmark sample consists of incumbents in the polluting industries without those who have investment related to ITC in the last 2 years but have no such investment in the current year